February 4, 2024

How Not Wearing a Seat Belt Affects Your Insurance Claim: Insights from a Personal Injury Lawyer

Understanding the Implications of Not Wearing a Seat Belt in an Accident

Does Not Wearing a Seatbelt Affect an Insurance Claim?

Yes, not wearing a seatbelt can affect an insurance claim. In the context of car accidents and personal injury cases, the principle of contributory negligence is often considered. This means if an individual is not wearing a seatbelt during an accident, it may be determined that their injuries were partly due to their own negligence. This can influence the outcome of an insurance claim in several ways:

  1. Fault Assessment: If it's found that not wearing a seatbelt contributed to the severity of the injuries, the individual may be deemed partially at fault for the damages they sustained.
  2. Compensation Reduction: Depending on the jurisdiction, this partial fault can lead to a reduction in the compensation amount. For instance, if a person is found 30% at fault for their injuries due to not wearing a seatbelt, their compensation may be reduced by 30%.
  3. Legal Requirements: Wearing a seatbelt is a legal requirement in many regions. Not adhering to this law can negatively impact an individual's claim, as it shows non-compliance with safety regulations.

So as you see, while not wearing a seatbelt does not automatically disqualify one from receiving compensation in an insurance claim, it can result in a reduced settlement amount due to contributory negligence.

Note: The contents of this post are not legal advice and are for educational purposes only. If you need help with a legal matter please consult with a qualified attorney. We offer free consultations for personal injury cases.

Free Consultations

We will review your case for free.

No Win, No Fee

Pay us nothing unless we get you a better settlement.

No Up-Front Fees

We work on contingency.

Where an accident occurs will determine what state or federal laws end up applying to the case. This is an important consideration. We have a post specifically for seatbelt laws affecting insurance claims in Oregon.

More On Seat Belt Implications

It's a common scenario in personal injury cases: "I wasn’t wearing a seat belt." If you're involved in a car accident, you might be concerned that not wearing a seat belt could negatively impact your ability to recover damages. It's a valid concern, given that wearing a seat belt is not only a safety best practice but also a legal requirement.

However, the reality is more nuanced. Not wearing a seat belt does not automatically disqualify you from seeking compensation. In this article, we'll explore how this factor influences insurance claims and the role of a Personal Injury Lawyer in these situations.

1. The Role of Contributory Negligence in Personal Injury Cases

In Oregon, (where our firm's headquarters is located) like in many states, the concept of contributory negligence plays a crucial role in determining the outcome of personal injury claims. This legal principle involves assessing the degree of fault of each party involved in an accident. If you were not wearing a seat belt during the accident, a jury might consider this as a contributing factor to the severity of your injuries.

Where your accident occurs will affect which laws apply to your case. While many states are similar there are differences, and even local city or county laws can come into play.

Let's delve deeper into how seatbelt use and non-use impacts your claim:

  • Determining Fault and Its Impact on Compensation: A jury will evaluate the facts of the case to ascertain each party's responsibility for the accident and the resulting injuries. In most states, if you, as the plaintiff, are found to be partially at fault for not wearing a seat belt, this will influence the compensation you may receive.
  • Understanding the 49% Rule: In Oregon and some other states, you can still recover damages if you are found to be 49% or less responsible for your injuries. For instance, if the jury finds that your lack of a seat belt contributed to 35% of your injuries, you would be eligible to receive 65% of the awarded damages. However, if your fault level reaches 50% or more, you would not be entitled to any compensation.

Oregon caps contributory negligence of seatbelt nonuse at 5%!

Oregon has a specific law covering contributory negligence due in relation to nonuse of a seatbelt.

Oregon law, particularly ORS 31.760, recognizes the importance of seatbelt use but also ensures that failing to wear a seatbelt does not substantially prevent you from seeking compensation for your injuries.

Here's how ORS 31.760 specifically affects your ability to make a claim:

  1. Introduction of Evidence: ORS 31.760 allows for evidence of not wearing a seatbelt to be introduced in a civil action related to a motor vehicle accident. This means that in a lawsuit, the other party can mention your failure to wear a seatbelt as part of their defense.
  2. Limited Impact on Damages: Importantly, the law limits the reduction of your damages due to not wearing a seatbelt. If it's found that your injuries were more severe because you weren't wearing a seatbelt, the reduction in the compensation you receive can be no more than 5% of the total damages awarded. This cap is designed to prevent the fact that you weren't wearing a seatbelt from having an overly punitive effect on your claim.

In essence, while not wearing a seatbelt can be factored into your case, ORS 31.760 ensures that it doesn't overly penalize you in terms of the compensation you can recover for injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident. This provision reflects Oregon's balanced approach to encouraging seatbelt use while still allowing for fair recovery of damages in personal injury claims.

Navigating the complexities of contributory negligence can be challenging, especially when dealing with the aftermath of an accident. A qualified Personal Injury Lawyer can be instrumental in these situations:

  • Advocating on Your Behalf: An experienced lawyer will work to minimize the impact of any factors that might be detrimental to your case, such as not wearing a seat belt.
  • Maximizing Your Compensation: By presenting a strong case and arguing effectively against an increased fault percentage, a lawyer can help ensure you receive the maximum possible compensation.

If you’ve been involved in an accident in Oregon and weren’t wearing a seat belt, it’s crucial to seek legal advice. At Johnson Law, P.C., our team of experienced personal injury lawyers is dedicated to advocating for your rights and guiding you through the legal process. For a comprehensive assessment of your case and personalized legal advice, contact us for a free consultation.

4. Navigating Seat Belt Laws and Personal Injury Claims in Oregon

Understanding how not wearing a seat belt can affect your insurance claim is crucial in personal injury cases. While it does not automatically bar you from recovering damages, it can significantly influence the outcome. With the expertise of a Personal Injury Lawyer, you can navigate these complexities and work towards a favorable resolution. Remember, safety and legal compliance, such as wearing a seat belt, are always your best defense on the road.

In Oregon, it will be up to a jury to assign fault in a case. They will examine the facts and make a determination as to how much each party contributed to the injury. If a person was not wearing a seat belt, the jury may decide that this contributed to the injury and assign a certain amount of fault to the plaintiff.

In order for a plaintiff to recover anything, they will need to be 49% or less responsible for the injuries. For instance, if a jury decides that the plaintiff is responsible for 35% of their injuries, the plaintiff will receive 65% of whatever amount the jury awards. If, however, the jury decides that the plaintiff is 50% at fault, the plaintiff will receive nothing. A Portland Personal Injury Lawyer will strongly advocate on your behalf, working to downplay any involvement you may have had in contributing to your injury.

If you have been hurt in an accident in Oregon, an attorney at Johnson Law, P.C. can help. For a free consultation with a Portland Personal Injury Lawyer, contact us right away.

FAQ - Seatbelt Insurance Claims

Can I make a claim if I wasn't wearing a seatbelt?

Details

Yes, you can make an insurance claim or pursue a personal injury lawsuit in Oregon even if you weren't wearing a seatbelt at the time of the accident. Oregon law, particularly ORS 31.760, recognizes the importance of seatbelt use but also ensures that failing to wear a seatbelt does not substantially prevent you from seeking compensation for your injuries.

Here's how ORS 31.760 specifically affects your ability to make a claim:

  1. Introduction of Evidence: ORS 31.760 allows for evidence of not wearing a seatbelt to be introduced in a civil action related to a motor vehicle accident. This means that in a lawsuit, the other party can mention your failure to wear a seatbelt as part of their defense.
  2. Limited Impact on Damages: Importantly, the law limits the reduction of your damages due to not wearing a seatbelt. If it's found that your injuries were more severe because you weren't wearing a seatbelt, the reduction in the compensation you receive can be no more than 5% of the total damages awarded. This cap is designed to prevent the fact that you weren't wearing a seatbelt from having an overly punitive effect on your claim.

In essence, while not wearing a seatbelt can be factored into your case, ORS 31.760 ensures that it doesn't overly penalize you in terms of the compensation you can recover for injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident. This provision reflects Oregon's balanced approach to encouraging seatbelt use while still allowing for fair recovery of damages in personal injury claims.

Free Consultations

We will review your case for free.

No Win, No Fee

Pay us nothing unless we get you a better settlement.

No Up-Front Fees

We work on contingency.

Your Questions Answered

Personal Injury consultations are free and come with no obligation. Request yours now.
(971) 205-3266
1323 NE Orenco Station Pkwy
Suite #210
Hillsboro, OR 97124

SECURE CONTACT FORM

    linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram